When a commercial lease ends, most landlords expect the space back in the condition the lease describes. That usually means removing the tenant improvements and fixtures the landlord does not want to keep, restoring the space to base building or a white-box standard, repairing damage, and handing over a clean, safe unit with keys and records. In Vancouver, that removal work is a renovation like any other, so it can need permits, a hazardous materials check and licensed trades. Planning it early keeps the handover on track.

This guide is for business owners, tenants, landlords and property managers with office, retail, restaurant, cafe, industrial or warehouse space in Vancouver and across Metro Vancouver. It covers the end of a lease. For the start, see our guides to the landlord work letter and warm shell vs cold shell. Every lease is different, and this is not legal advice. Check your own lease and talk with your landlord, and get legal advice on what the wording means.

TL;DR

  • Make-good is whatever your lease says the space must look like at handover, often removal of tenant work plus restoration.
  • In Vancouver, taking out partitions, wiring, plumbing, sprinkler or fire alarm work can need building and trade permits, with inspections to close them.
  • A hazardous materials check comes before any strip-out, and a clean handover includes the paperwork as well as the keys.

What does make-good mean in a commercial lease?

Make-good, restoration and reinstatement are common names for the lease terms that set the condition of the space at the end of the term. They often work together with the alterations clause, which covers the landlord's consent to the work you built.

In practice, a lease tends to point to one of three outcomes for each improvement:

  • It stays. The improvement becomes part of the premises and the landlord keeps it.
  • It goes. The tenant removes it and repairs any damage caused by the removal.
  • The landlord decides. The landlord chooses near the end of the term which items stay and which must be removed.

If you are still negotiating a lease, our guide to tenant improvement allowance negotiation covers make-good terms at the signing stage.

What do landlords usually expect at handover?

Every building is different, but these items come up often:

  • Removal of tenant-installed partitions, private offices, millwork, signage and branded finishes.
  • Removal of data and phone cabling, security and access control equipment, and specialty lighting.
  • Removal of specialty items such as commercial kitchen equipment, walk-in coolers, safes, raised floors or warehouse storage racks, with gas and electrical disconnections done by licensed trades.
  • Services made safe and returned to the base building: electrical circuits removed or made safe, plumbing lines capped, and sprinkler and fire alarm devices suited to the restored layout.
  • Repairs: patched and painted walls, damaged ceiling tiles replaced, and flooring repaired or removed as the lease requires.
  • A clean, empty unit with all keys, fobs and access cards returned.

What is the difference between make-good, white box and leaving improvements in place?

These terms are often mixed up:

  • Full restoration returns the space to its original base-building or shell condition.
  • White box (sometimes called vanilla shell) usually means finished walls ready for paint, a basic ceiling and lighting, working washrooms and services, ready for the next tenant to fit out. Landlords use the label loosely, so the written scope is what counts. Our warm shell vs cold shell guide explains the related delivery conditions.
  • Leaving improvements in place is common when a landlord wants to market a ready-to-use office or retail layout to the next tenant.

Either way, start with a written list of what stays, what goes and what standard the space must meet, agreed with the landlord before the work is scoped.

Does make-good work need a permit in Vancouver?

Often, yes. The City of Vancouver treats removal work like any other renovation, and it lists tenant improvements for commercial spaces among the work that generally needs a permit. The main rules:

  • Interior demolition. The City's demolition bulletin says that demolishing interior partitions, or only part of a building, needs a building permit to alter the building. A demolition permit is for removing a whole building. Our guide to demolition permits in Vancouver explains the difference.
  • Electrical. An electrical permit is needed for almost all electrical work, applied for by a licensed electrical contractor. If the project needs a building permit, the electrical permit is issued after it.
  • Plumbing. A plumbing permit is needed to install, change or upgrade any part of a plumbing system. Removing fixtures and capping lines a tenant added changes the system, so it usually needs one.
  • Sprinklers. Any change to sprinkler piping needs a fire sprinkler permit from a licensed fire sprinkler contractor, and it is only valid once any required building permit is issued. Simple head or valve replacements do not need one.
  • Fire alarm. The City's fire alarm bulletin covers fire alarm changes triggered by a tenant improvement. Modifying an existing system needs an electrical permit, a building permit is also needed when wiring is extended or the zoning or sequence of operation changes, and the system has to be verified after the work.

The City's trade permit pages also note that all work must be inspected for the permit to be finalized. Outside Vancouver, Burnaby, Surrey, Richmond and the other Metro Vancouver municipalities run their own permits and inspections, so check with the local building department. For an overview of the permit process, see commercial building permits in Vancouver.

What about asbestos and other hazardous materials?

Under section 20.112 of the Occupational Health and Safety Regulation, before renovation or demolition work begins, the owner and the employers responsible must have a qualified person inspect the space and identify any hazardous materials, such as asbestos or lead, in a written report. Any identified material the work could disturb must be safely contained or removed before that work goes ahead.

If asbestos has to be removed, the abatement contractor must hold a valid licence from WorkSafeBC, and the owner and prime contractor must check it before the work starts. WorkSafeBC keeps a registry of licensed asbestos abatement contractors. Some asbestos and lead work also needs a notice of project sent to WorkSafeBC at least 48 hours before it begins.

Ask the landlord what reports already exist and whether they cover the areas and materials you plan to remove.

What happens to the materials that come out?

Metro Vancouver's disposal ban program keeps certain materials out of regional garbage facilities, including gypsum (drywall), corrugated cardboard and clean wood. Loads are inspected and can be surcharged when they contain banned materials, so a strip-out should be planned with sorting and recycling in mind.

How should tenants and landlords plan a smooth handover?

A clean handover comes down to order:

  • Read the lease early. List what the lease, the alteration consents and the landlord's rules say about make-good, and confirm the landlord's choices in writing.
  • Walk the space together. Compare it with any move-in condition records and the drawings for the work that was built.
  • Scope and check. Turn the list into a written scope, arrange the hazardous materials check, and identify which permits are needed.
  • Plan around the building. Book elevators and loading areas, follow the building's rules for noisy work, and protect neighbouring tenants. Our guide to renovating a commercial building while it stays open covers working around other occupants.
  • Do the work and close it out. Book the inspections and finalize the permits, then work through a final punch list with the landlord.
  • Hand over the records. Keys and access cards, finalized permits and inspection records, hazardous materials reports and clearance letters, and updated as-built drawings where the lease or landlord asks for them.

How Multigroup Contracting helps

Multigroup Contracting is a commercial general contractor and fee-based construction manager founded in 2016, with our Vancouver office at 700-838 West Hastings St. We are registered with WorkSafeBC and carry $5M in liability insurance. We help tenants scope and complete make-good work, and we help landlords and property managers get spaces ready for the next tenant, coordinating hazardous materials consultants, licensed trades, permits and inspections. See our tenant improvements, office fit-outs, retail buildouts, warehouse renovations and commercial construction services.

Tell us about your space and what your lease asks for. Get a free quote, call 778-819-5933 or email info@multigroup.ca.

FAQ

What is a make-good clause in a commercial lease?

It is the part of a lease that says what condition the space must be in when the tenant leaves. It often asks the tenant to remove its improvements and restore the space. Wording differs from lease to lease, so read your own lease and confirm the details with your landlord.

Does removing tenant improvements need a permit in Vancouver?

Often, yes. The City of Vancouver says demolishing interior partitions needs a building permit to alter the building, and electrical, plumbing, fire sprinkler and fire alarm changes need their own permits. Permitted work must be inspected before the permit is finalized.

Is a white box the same as make-good?

Not always. A white box usually means a clean, basic space with finished walls, a ceiling, lighting and washrooms, ready for the next tenant's fit-out. Make-good means whatever your lease requires, which may be more or less than that, so put the agreed scope in writing.

Do I need a hazardous materials survey before make-good work in BC?

Yes. Before renovation or demolition work begins, the WorkSafeBC Occupational Health and Safety Regulation requires the owner and the employers responsible to have a qualified person identify hazardous materials such as asbestos and lead. Materials the work could disturb must be safely contained or removed first.

Can a landlord choose to keep the tenant improvements?

Some leases let the landlord decide which improvements stay and which must be removed, and some landlords prefer to keep a usable layout for the next tenant. It depends on your lease, so confirm the landlord's choice in writing before the work is scoped.

Sources