An empty shell office suite gives you a clean slate: you design and build almost everything, but nothing has to come out first. A second-generation office already has walls, ceilings, lighting, sprinklers and sometimes washrooms from a previous tenant, so the scope depends on how much of that you can reuse. In Vancouver, the starting condition also shapes the permit path, the hazardous materials work under WorkSafeBC rules and the factors that drive your schedule, so check it before you sign the lease.
This guide is for office tenants, landlords and property managers comparing suites in Vancouver and Metro Vancouver. For what "warm shell" and "cold shell" mean in a lease, see our guide to warm shell vs cold shell.
What is the difference between an empty shell and a second-generation office?
An empty shell suite, sometimes called a base-building shell, has the structure, exterior walls, base-building systems and shared services in place, but little or no tenant work inside. What else is included depends on the lease.
A second-generation office was built out for an earlier tenant. It usually has some mix of:
- Partitions, offices and meeting rooms in an existing layout.
- A finished ceiling with lighting, sprinkler heads and fire alarm devices placed for that layout.
- Doors, glazing, flooring and millwork.
- In some suites, a kitchenette, in-suite washrooms or a server room.
Neither label tells you what is actually there. Get the delivery condition in writing, check what the landlord work letter covers, and walk the suite with your designer and contractor before you commit.
How does the starting condition change the scope of work?
In an empty shell, the scope is mostly new construction: partitions, doors, ceilings, lighting, power and data, sprinkler heads, fire alarm devices, finishes and any washrooms or kitchenette. There is little to remove, and no earlier tenant's choices limit the design.
In a second-generation office, the scope splits into three parts:
- Keep: items that suit your plan and are in good condition, such as a ceiling grid, perimeter offices or a washroom core.
- Modify: items that stay but change, such as relocated sprinkler heads, new lighting in an existing ceiling or doors moved to new openings.
- Remove: items that do not fit, which become selective demolition.
The closer the existing layout is to your needs, the more you can keep. When it is far off, a second-generation suite can end up with the scope of an empty shell plus demolition. Our tenant improvement scope of work guide explains how to write that split down.
What should you check in a second-generation office before reusing it?
Before you plan around existing work, check:
- Sprinkler and fire alarm layout: new walls and rooms often mean heads and devices have to move or be added.
- Ceilings and lighting: whether the grid, tiles and fixtures are in good condition and can be rearranged.
- Exits and doors: whether the old exit paths still work for your plan.
- Washrooms and kitchenettes: whether they meet current requirements, including accessibility, for the way you will use them.
- Record drawings and reports: whether the landlord has drawings of the previous fit-out and any existing hazardous materials report.
Our guide to fire and life safety in commercial renovations covers how exits, rated walls, sprinklers and fire alarm shape the layout.
Why does demolition in a second-generation office need a hazardous materials survey?
Under WorkSafeBC rules, a qualified person must conduct a hazardous materials survey before any renovation or demolition work. The Occupational Health and Safety Regulation, Part 20 puts that duty on the owner and the employers responsible for the work, and the qualified person must produce a written report of what was found, such as asbestos-containing material or lead.
That matters most in second-generation space, where earlier walls, ceilings and flooring will be disturbed. If asbestos or lead is found, it has to be dealt with safely before the related demolition goes ahead, and certain asbestos and lead work also requires a WorkSafeBC Notice of Project. Our guides to WorkSafeBC Notice of Project and demolition permits in Vancouver cover both steps.
How does the starting condition change the permit?
The City of Vancouver says construction projects and changes of use or occupancy on private property require a building permit. What changes with the starting condition is which path the permit takes and what goes with it.
- First tenant improvement in a new shell: the City's minor renovation submission checklist lists a Building Permit Data Sheet as required for the first tenant improvement in a newly constructed shell space. In a new building, the City's decision tree for tenant improvements in Certified Professional base buildings notes that a TI permit may be issued before the base building's occupancy permit, but the tenant space may not receive occupancy before the base building.
- Second-generation office in an eligible building: the City's Tenant Improvement Program (TIPs) is a dedicated stream for office tenants in eligible commercial buildings doing minor interior renovations. If the work moves or adds up to 20 sprinkler heads, a sprinkler contractor can apply for the sprinkler permit.
- Bigger changes: TIPs does not cover projects involving interconnecting floors, upgrading existing systems, fire alarms, sprinkler systems or seismic upgrading, new mezzanines or most major renovations. Those need a standard building permit.
Our tenant improvement permit guide walks through the City's process in more detail.
When can renovating existing office space trigger building upgrades?
In Vancouver, work on existing buildings falls under Part 11 of the Vancouver Building By-law. The Notes to Part 11 describe a minor renovation as work within a single suite and its shared demising walls that does not include the building's public or common areas. Renovations beyond that are generally major renovations.
Part 11's upgrade mechanism sets required upgrade levels for fire and life safety, structure, non-structural falling hazards and accessibility based on the type of project. Your designer or code consultant confirms which category applies.
Elsewhere in Metro Vancouver, the 2024 BC Building Code applies and each municipality runs its own permit process.
How does the starting condition affect the schedule?
Every suite is different, but each starting condition has its own schedule drivers:
- Empty shell: more design, new work and items to order. In a new building, the base building's own occupancy can limit when you move in.
- Second-generation office: less new work when reuse is high, but a hazardous materials survey and any abatement come before demolition, and hidden conditions behind walls and above ceilings can change the plan once opened up.
- Both: landlord approval of drawings, the permit path and the availability of long-lead items.
For the full sequence, see our office buildout timeline guide and our guide to landlord approval for a commercial fit-out.
How Multigroup Contracting helps
Multigroup Contracting is a commercial general contractor and fee-based construction manager based in Vancouver, founded in 2016. We are registered with WorkSafeBC and carry $5M in liability insurance. We review existing suites, help sort out what can be reused, and build office fit-outs and tenant improvements across Metro Vancouver, in empty shell and second-generation space.
Comparing office suites in Vancouver or Metro Vancouver? Get a free quote, call Multigroup Contracting at 778-819-5933 or email info@multigroup.ca. Our Vancouver office is at 700-838 West Hastings St.
FAQ
What is the difference between an empty shell and a second-generation office?
An empty shell suite has the base building in place but little or no tenant work inside, so walls, ceilings, lighting and most services still have to be built. A second-generation office still has a previous tenant's build-out, such as partitions, ceilings, lighting, sprinkler heads and sometimes washrooms.
Is a second-generation office always simpler to build out?
Not always. It is when the existing layout is close to what you need. When it is not, a hazardous materials survey, selective demolition and changes to existing sprinklers, lighting and ceilings add scope an empty shell does not have.
Do I need a building permit to renovate a second-generation office in Vancouver?
In most cases, yes. The City of Vancouver says construction projects and changes of use or occupancy on private property require a building permit. Minor interior renovations in eligible office buildings may use the City's Tenant Improvement Program, while upgrading sprinkler or fire alarm systems needs a standard building permit.
Do I need a hazardous materials survey before demolishing an existing office fit-out?
Yes. WorkSafeBC requires the owner and the employers responsible for the work to have a qualified person inspect the building for hazardous materials, such as asbestos and lead, before renovation or demolition work begins, and to have a written report of what was found.
Does a first tenant improvement in a new shell space need anything extra for the permit?
Yes. The City of Vancouver's minor renovation checklist requires a Building Permit Data Sheet for the first tenant improvement in a newly constructed shell space. In a new building, the tenant space also cannot receive occupancy before the base building.
Sources
- Get a building permit, City of Vancouver
- Tenant Improvement Program (TIPs), City of Vancouver
- Field Review and TIPs Minor Renovation Building Permit Submission Checklist, City of Vancouver
- Decision Tree for Use of CP-3 (first tenant improvement), City of Vancouver
- Vancouver Building By-law, City of Vancouver
- Vancouver Building By-law, Notes to Part 11 Existing Buildings, City of Vancouver
- Vancouver Building By-law, Section 11.5 Upgrade Mechanism, City of Vancouver
- 2024 BC Building Code, Province of British Columbia
- Health and safety resources for your next building project, WorkSafeBC
- OHS Regulation Part 20: Construction, Excavation and Demolition, WorkSafeBC
- Asbestos, WorkSafeBC